Critical Thinking
Coverage of Critical Thinking in the Nexus archive.
- Is AI making us dumber?
The article discusses concerns that generative AI may weaken mental persistence, creativity, and critical thinking, drawing parallels to past debates about the 'Google effect.' Researcher Nataliya Kosmyna highlights AI's potential to degrade cognitive skills more than previous technologies like calculators, citing studies showing declining performance in AI-assisted essay writing. The piece contrasts fears of cognitive decline with historical examples where technological advancements (e.g., calculators, the internet) caused gradual but not catastrophic changes.
- Jack Clark: AI itself can stem cognitive decline
Jack Clark, co-founder of Anthropic, suggests AI systems can help prevent cognitive decline by encouraging critical thinking. Anthropic's Claude chatbot asks clarifying questions to engage users, with future versions potentially requiring original ideas. However, users may resist increased friction in the experience.
- In the era of AI, schools want students to think critically. Experts say they need knowledge to do so.
Educators in New York City participated in a training session on fostering critical thinking in the age of AI, organized by the National Academy for AI Instruction. The article highlights debates about balancing abstract critical thinking skills with content knowledge in subjects like math and history, citing research that domain-specific knowledge is essential for effective critical thinking.
- AI chatbots could be making you stupider
A BBC article explores concerns that AI chatbots may be reducing critical thinking skills in users. The piece highlights debates around the cognitive impact of relying on AI for information and decision-making.
- Schools Never Taught Critical Thinking: AI Exposed the Lie
The article claims schools failed to teach critical thinking skills, which AI technology has revealed through its capabilities. It highlights a gap in traditional education systems.